{
  "$schema": "folio-library-entry/v1",
  "id": "10665-196326",
  "blocks": [
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-front-matter",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Front matter",
      "pageStart": 1,
      "pageEnd": 7,
      "target": "../sections/sec-front-matter.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "Training manual\nEthics in epidemics, \nemergencies and disasters: \nResearch, surveillance\nand patient care\nEthics in epidemics, emergencies \nand disasters:\nresearch, surveillance and patient care\nTraining manual\nWHO Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data\nEthics in epidemics, emergencies and disasters: research, surveillance and patient care: training manual.\n1. Ethics. 2. Epidemics. 3. Disease Outbreaks. 4. Research. 5. Public Health Surveillance. 6. Emergencies. \n7. Patient Care. I. World Health Organization. \nISBN 978 92 4 154934 9  (NLM classification: W 50)\n© World Health Organization 2015",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "The front matter of the English training manual on ethics in epidemics, emergencies and disasters, with title pages, cataloguing data and ISBN, WHO copyright and disclaimer text, and the table of contents.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-000",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Contributors",
      "pageStart": 7,
      "pageEnd": 9,
      "target": "../sections/sec-000-contributors.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "Contributors\nBaxter, Michael, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada\nBoulanger, Renaud F., Faculty of Medicine, McGill University, Montréal, Québec, Canada\nCalain, Philippe, Médecins Sans Frontières, Geneva, Switzerland\nClarinval, Caroline, Institute of Biomedical Ethics and History of Medicine, University of Zurich, Switzerland\nColeman, Carl H., Seton Hall University School of Law, Newark, New Jersey, United States of America\nGillespie, Leigh‑Anne, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada\nGoodman, Kenneth, Institute for Bioethics and Health Policy, University of Miami Miller Sch",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "The list of contributors to the manual, giving each author's name and institutional affiliation.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-001",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Acknowledgements",
      "pageStart": 9,
      "pageEnd": 11,
      "target": "../sections/sec-001-acknowledgements.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "Acknowledgements\nThis training manual is the result of the collaboration of the WHO Global Health Ethics Unit (GHE) in the \nDepartment of Knowledge, Ethics and Research (KER), the Department of Emergency Risk Management \nand Humanitarian Response (ERM) and the Department of Pandemic and Epidemic Diseases (PED). The \ndevelopment of this manual was led by Andreas Reis (GHE) with assistance from Abha Saxena, Coordinator \nGHE, and Jonathan Abrahams, ERM department.\nSpecial thanks go to Philippe Calain for overseeing the initial phase and design of the project and to Renaud \nBoulanger for coordinat",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Acknowledges the WHO units that produced the training manual and the staff who led it, noting it grew out of a 2009 WHO technical consultation on research ethics in epidemic response. It thanks chapter authors, publishers who allowed material to be reused, and many external reviewers. It also credits student workshops and 2015 pilot sessions in Guinea, Liberia and Sierra Leone that tested draft modules.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-002",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Introduction",
      "pageStart": 11,
      "pageEnd": 14,
      "target": "../sections/sec-002-introduction.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "Epidemics, emergencies and disasters raise many ethical issues for the people involved, who include \nresponders, public health specialists and policy‑makers. This training manual provides material on ethical \nissues in research, surveillance and patient care in these difficult contexts, as well as related issues to reduce \nrisks before, during and after events.\nThe idea for this manual can be traced back to a  WHO technical consultation on Research ethics in \ninternational epidemic response (World Health Organization, 2010). In the resulting report, the experts took \npositions on three main is",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Introduces the manual's aim of providing training material on ethics in research, surveillance and patient care during epidemics, emergencies and disasters. It recalls the 2009 WHO consultation's positions on upholding ethics guidelines, the blurred line between practice and research, and adapting ethics oversight. It also explains how emergencies and disasters are understood, including natural and human-induced hazards, and ends with references.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-003",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Overview: Ethics in epidemics, emergencies and disasters",
      "pageStart": 14,
      "pageEnd": 19,
      "target": "../sections/sec-003-overview-ethics-in-epidemics-emergencies-and-dis.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "Session timeline (90 min)\n0–30 min\n(30 min)\n31–45 min\n(15 min)\n41–80 min\n(40 min)\n81–90 min\n(10 min)\nPlenary presentation\nOpen discussion\nGroup activity\nSummary and conclusion\nGroup work\nPresentation\nInstruction strategy\nFor facilitators: This session provides an overview of the material in the manual; only some aspects are \ncovered and only superficially. In training sessions for which time is limited, only the plenary part of the \nsession can be given, which will take approximately 45 min. When more time is available, the group activity \ncan be added, bringing the session to approximately 90",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Sets out a 90-minute overview session on ethics in epidemics, emergencies and disasters, with a plenary presentation, open discussion and group work. Facilitators are told how to shorten the session and how to run the group activity. The two case studies on allocating intravenous fluids and designing a clinical trial during a haemorrhagic fever outbreak are reproduced with their discussion questions.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-004",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Research and surveillance",
      "pageStart": 19,
      "pageEnd": 21,
      "target": "../sections/sec-004-research-and-surveillance.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "surveillance",
      "truncated": false,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "A near-empty section heading for the research and surveillance part, containing only a single word.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/figure-img-p021-1",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Figure",
        "doco:Figure"
      ],
      "kind": "figure",
      "title": "",
      "pageStart": 21,
      "pageEnd": 21,
      "target": "../images/img-p021-1.webp",
      "narrative": "draft",
      "content": "Photograph of a person wearing a respirator mask and gloves holding up a small labelled sample vial containing pink liquid.",
      "truncated": false,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": null
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-005",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Core competence 1: Ability to analyse the boundaries between public health practice, including surveillance, and research and their ethical implications in emergencies",
      "pageStart": 21,
      "pageEnd": 23,
      "target": "../sections/sec-005-core-competence-1-ability-to-analyse-the-boundar.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "Ability to analyse the boundaries \nbetween public health \npractice, including surveillance, \nand research and their ethical \nimplications in emergencies\nAvian influenza in Indonesia \nSource: WHO/Gary Hampton\nCore competence 1: Ability to analyse the boundaries between public \nhealth practice, including surveillance, and research and their ethical \nimplications in public health emergencies\nThe criterion still predominantly used to determine whether ethics oversight of public health activities is \nneeded is a distinction between the definitions of public health practice and research. The use of",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Introduces core competence 1, on analysing the boundary between public health practice, including surveillance, and research during emergencies. It explains that this distinction still largely decides whether ethics oversight is required and lists the four learning objectives.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-006",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Learning objective 1.1: Distinguish between public health surveillance and public health research.",
      "pageStart": 23,
      "pageEnd": 29,
      "target": "../sections/sec-006-learning-objective-11-distinguish-between-public.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "and public health research.\nMichael J. Selgelid\nSession timeline (60 min)\n0–15 min\n(15 min)\n16–20 min\n(5 min)\n21–40 min\n(20 min)\n41–55 min\n(15 min)\n56–60 min\n(5 min)\nIntroduction\nReading\nTeam preparation\nTeam presentations \nand discussion\nSummary and \nconclusion\nInstruction strategy\n1.\t\nThe facilitator begins the session by presenting a general overview of the issue, using the slides provided \nas a guide.\nFor facilitators: Include a brief group discussion of the questions raised on the slides. See: http://www.who.\nint/ethics/topics/outbreaks-emergencies/en/.\n2.\t\nThe facilitator distributes sce",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Sets out a 60-minute session on distinguishing public health surveillance from research, with team work on scenarios. The background defines public health and describes surveillance as a core activity that tracks disease patterns and guides control measures. It discusses why the line between research and surveillance is hard to draw, including tensions between informed consent and the goals of surveillance. The section closes with references and further reading.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-007",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Learning objective 1.2: Identify the scope of activities that could qualify as “research” during emergency response and would normally require research ethics review.",
      "pageStart": 29,
      "pageEnd": 34,
      "target": "../sections/sec-007-learning-objective-12-identify-the-scope-of-acti.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "as “research” during emergency response and would normally require \nresearch ethics review.\nRenaud F. Boulanger and Matthew R. Hunt\nSession timeline (85 min)\n0–30 min\n(30 min)\n31–50 min\n(20 min)\n51–75 min\n(25 min)\n76–90 min\n(15 min)\nIntroduction and small slide presentation\nTeam \npreparation\nTeam presentations \nand discussion\nSummary and\nconclusion\nInstruction strategy\n1.\t\nThe facilitator introduces the module and provides a brief background on research ethics committees, \nusing the slides. See: http://www.who.int/ethics/topics/outbreaks-emergencies/en/.\n2.\t\nThe facilitator distributes a copy",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Describes a session on which activities count as research during emergency response and normally need ethics review, using a team exercise where groups design a project and others judge its type. The background explains that research is usually subject to independent ethics review while public health practice often is not. It outlines categories of research, such as clinical, health services and population-based studies, with examples, followed by references.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-008",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Learning objective 1.3: Demonstrate understanding of the ethical principles and requirements addressed in current normative instruments relative to research and surveillance in emergencies.",
      "pageStart": 34,
      "pageEnd": 44,
      "target": "../sections/sec-008-learning-objective-13-demonstrate-understanding.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "principles and requirements addressed in current normative \ninstruments relative to research and surveillance in emergencies.\nGhaiath Hussein\nSession timeline (90 min)\n0–15 min\n(15 min)\n16–35 min\n(20 min)\n36–50 min\n(15 min)\n51–80 min\n(30 min)\n81–90 min\n(10 min)\nIntroduction\nReading\nGroup discussion\nSlide presentation on \nethics guidelines\nDiscussion and \nconclusion\nInstruction strategy\n1.\t\nThe facilitator introduces the learning objective (15 min).\nFor facilitators: Ask the participants if they had ever had to use a “research ethics guideline” in their practice \nor if they have heard of such d",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Describes a 90-minute session on the ethical principles and requirements in current normative instruments for research and surveillance in emergencies. Participants read papers on what makes clinical research ethical, including in developing countries, before a presentation on major research ethics guidelines. The background traces the history of research ethics and the protections it offers participants, while noting debate about whether differences between research and public health practice should decide ethics review. References at the end include material on a disputed drug trial in Nigeria.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/table-001",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Table",
        "doco:Table"
      ],
      "kind": "table",
      "title": "Table 1. Core ethical principles and issues covered by the main guidelines and examples of their application in emergencies",
      "pageStart": 36,
      "pageEnd": 37,
      "target": "../tables/table-1.csv",
      "narrative": "draft",
      "content": "Eight core research-ethics principles and issues (autonomy, informed consent, beneficence, non-maleficence, justice, vulnerability, privacy, confidentiality), each with a definition, an example of its application in emergencies and examples of guidelines that address it (CIOMS, Declaration of Helsinki, Belmont Report, Tri-Council Policy Statement, Common Rule).",
      "truncated": false,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": null
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-009",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Learning objective 1.4: Identify the shortcomings of current normative instruments for use in emergency situations, and evaluate alternatives.",
      "pageStart": 44,
      "pageEnd": 53,
      "target": "../sections/sec-009-learning-objective-14-identify-the-shortcomings.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "instruments for use in emergency situations, and evaluate alternatives.\nGhaiath Hussein\nSession timeline (120 min)\n0–5 min\n(5 min)\n6–10 min\n(5 min)\n11-30 min\n(20 min)\n31–40 min\n(10 min)\n41–55 min\n(15 min)\n56–70 min\n(15 min)\n71–85 min\n(15 min)\n86–110 min\n(25 min)\n111–\n120 min\n(10 min)\nReview of \nlearning \nobjective 1.3\nProbing \nquestions\nReading \nand case \nstudy and \ndiscussion\nReporting \nback\nSlide \npresentation\nReading\nGroup \ndiscussion\nWriting\nSummary \nand \nconclusion\nInstruction strategy\n1.\t\nThe facilitator reviews the main guidelines and core principles of research ethics studied in learni",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "A training module, part of a course on ethics in emergencies and epidemics, on the shortcomings of existing research ethics guidelines and regulations when applied to emergencies. It gives a 120-minute session plan in which trainees test a guideline against a case study involving issues such as child vulnerability, consent across language barriers, confidentiality and conflicts of interest, then draft their own ethical framework. The background notes that most guidelines were written for clinical research in stable, well-resourced settings, while urgency in emergencies should not excuse ignoring core principles, citing the WHO panel on unregistered Ebola interventions. It then discusses altered perceptions of ethical issues, the patient–provider relationship, study integrity and ethics review, ending with references.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/figure-img-p053-1",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Figure",
        "doco:Figure"
      ],
      "kind": "figure",
      "title": "",
      "pageStart": 53,
      "pageEnd": 53,
      "target": "../images/img-p053-1.webp",
      "narrative": "draft",
      "content": "Photograph of a group of people seated around joined tables in a meeting room, taking notes; one person wears a vest with a WHO emblem.",
      "truncated": false,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": null
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-010",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Core competence 2: Ability to define adequate processes for ethics review in public health interventions, surveillance and research in emergencies",
      "pageStart": 53,
      "pageEnd": 55,
      "target": "../sections/sec-010-core-competence-2-ability-to-define-adequate-pro.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "Ability to define adequate \nprocesses for ethics \nreview in public health \ninterventions, surveillance and \nresearch in emergencies\nSource: WHO\nSource: WHO\nCore competence 2: Ability to define adequate processes for ethics \nreview in public health interventions, surveillance and research in \nemergencies\nWhen ethics oversight is deemed necessary for public health activities, it is important that such oversight \nbe of high quality. The standard procedures that should be followed in the case of research are described in \nlearning objective 2.1. Learning objective 2.2 describes the circumstances i",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Introduces the second core competence of the course, on defining sound ethics review processes for public health interventions, surveillance and research in emergencies, and lists its three learning objectives on standard review, review of surveillance and variations for emergencies.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-011",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Learning objective 2.1: Describe “standard” procedures that should govern an ethics review of research activities, including public health research.",
      "pageStart": 55,
      "pageEnd": 62,
      "target": "../sections/sec-011-learning-objective-21-describe-standard-procedur.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "govern an ethics review of research activities, including public health \nresearch.\nKenneth W. Goodman and Sergio Litewka\nSession timeline (90 min)\n0–20 min\n(20 min)\n21–45 min\n(25 min)\n46–70 min\n(25 min)\n71–85 min\n(15 min)\n86–90 min\n(5 min)\nIntroduction\nDebate\nCase study and \ndiscussion\nDiscussion\nSummary and \nconclusion\nInstruction strategy\n1.\t\nThe facilitator introduces the module and provides background information on “standard” procedures \nfor ethics review.\n2.\t\nThe facilitator identifies key (conceptual) differences between biomedical research and public health \nresearch.\n3.\t\nThe facilitat",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "A training module describing the standard procedures that should govern ethics review of research, including public health research. Its 90-minute session plan uses a debate and a case that falls between research and surveillance to ask whether review standards could ever be altered and whether committee review is worth its cost. The background explains why prospective independent review is now broadly accepted, how multidisciplinary committees with lay members work and that review is not meant to obstruct research. It lists eleven areas a review should cover, from social value and informed consent to community participation, risk minimization and international collaboration, and ends with references and further reading.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-012",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Learning objective 2.2: Identify circumstances in which public health surveillance activities should possibly undergo formal ethics review.",
      "pageStart": 62,
      "pageEnd": 68,
      "target": "../sections/sec-012-learning-objective-22-identify-circumstances-in.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "surveillance activities should possibly undergo formal ethics review.\nKenneth W. Goodman\nSession timeline: 75 min\n0–25 min\n(25 min)\n26-30 min\n(5 min)\n31–45 min\n(15 min)\n46–65 min\n(20 min)\n65–75 min\n(10 min)\nIntroduction\nReading\nCase study and \ndiscussion\nDebate\nSummary and \nconclusion\nInstruction strategy\n1.\t\nThe facilitator introduces the module.\n2.\t\nThe facilitator splits the group into two and asks participants to explore why surveillance might \nsometimes have to be reviewed by research ethics committees.\nFor facilitators: Emphasize differences between laws and regulations and ethics by exp",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "A training module on when public health surveillance should undergo formal ethics review. Its 75-minute session plan uses a hospital testing case and group debate on which kinds of surveillance need review and which do not. The background explores the elusive line between surveillance and research, noting that research usually involves an intervention with quantifiable risk while much surveillance relies on data people may not know are collected. It discusses the ethical basis for oversight, including mutual responsibility, public trust and past misuse of HIV data, and ends by noting calls for risk-based rather than definition-based approaches, followed by references.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-013",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Learning objective 2.3: Describe possible variations to standard procedures of ethics review that are applicable to research in emergencies.",
      "pageStart": 68,
      "pageEnd": 77,
      "target": "../sections/sec-013-learning-objective-23-describe-possible-variatio.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "procedures of ethics review that are applicable to research in \nemergencies.\nAthula Sumathipala\nSession timeline (75 min)\n0–5 min\n(5 min)\n6–15 min\n(10 min)\n16–30 min\n(15 min)\n31–40 min\n(10 min)\n41–65 min\n(25 min)\n66–75 min\n(10 min)\nIntroduction\nSmall group \ndiscussion\nGroup discussion\nSlide \npresentation\nCase study and \ndiscussion\nSummary and\nconclusion\nInstruction strategy\n1.\t\nThe facilitator introduces the module and briefly reminds participants of the standard procedures for \nethics review (see learning objective 2.1) (5 min).\n2.\t\nThe facilitator asks participants to reflect on the followin",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "A training module on possible variations to standard ethics review procedures for research carried out during emergencies. Its 75-minute session plan combines group reflection, slides and two case studies asking whether projects are research or surveillance and whether expedited review or lighter consent procedures are acceptable. The background argues that research in emergencies is needed but must not exploit resource-poor settings, and sets out the debate over whether disaster survivors are inherently vulnerable. Proposed variations include expedited review, proportionality of risks and benefits, special scrutiny, generic anticipatory protocols and proactive review, with references at the end.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/figure-img-p077-1",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Figure",
        "doco:Figure"
      ],
      "kind": "figure",
      "title": "",
      "pageStart": 77,
      "pageEnd": 77,
      "target": "../images/img-p077-1.webp",
      "narrative": "draft",
      "content": "Photograph of a worker in a full white protective suit, goggles and green gloves using a backpack sprayer, while women and children watch from in front of a thatched wall.",
      "truncated": false,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": null
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-014",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Core competence 3: Ability to identify conflict between the common good and individual autonomy in surveillance during emergency response",
      "pageStart": 77,
      "pageEnd": 79,
      "target": "../sections/sec-014-core-competence-3-ability-to-identify-conflict-b.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "Ability to identify conflict \nbetween the common \ngood and individual autonomy \nin surveillance during \nemergency response\nLocal health staff work with experts from Médecins Sans Frontières to disinfect the \nhouse of a patient who died of Ebola. Democratic Republic of the Congo, 2007.\nSource: WHO/Christopher Black\nCore competence 3: Ability to identify conflict between the common \ngood and individual autonomy in surveillance during emergency \nresponse\nEven though public health practice, including surveillance, is meant to improve the common good or the \naggregate public welfare, it can harm in",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Introduces the third core competence of the course, on recognizing conflicts between the common good and individual autonomy in emergency surveillance. It outlines five learning objectives covering harms and benefits, when informed consent is needed, privacy and confidentiality, protection of biological materials, and when the common good may override autonomy.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-015",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Learning objective 3.1: Identify possible harm and benefit to individuals and communities resulting from public health practice and surveillance.",
      "pageStart": 79,
      "pageEnd": 86,
      "target": "../sections/sec-015-learning-objective-31-identify-possible-harm-and.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "and communities resulting from public health practice and surveillance.\nDónal O’Mathúna\nSession timeline (105 min)\n0–5 min\n(5 min)\n6–25 min\n(20 min)\n26–30 min\n(5 min)\n31–35 min\n(5 min)\n36–50 min\n(15 min)\n51–60 min\n(10 min)\n61–70 min\n(10 min)\n71–100 \nmin\n(30 min)\n101–\n105 min\n(5 min)\nWriting \nand discussion\nIntroduction\nWriting\nReading\nGroup \ndiscussion\nClass \ndiscussion\nSlide\npresentation\nCase \nstudy and \ndiscussion\nSummary \nand \nconclusion\nInstruction strategy\n1.\t\nThe facilitator asks participants to write a brief answer to the following question and share their answer \nwith the group: Under",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "A training module on the harms and benefits that public health practice and surveillance can bring to individuals and communities. Its 105-minute session plan includes writing exercises on when quarantine is justified, use of the Nuffield intervention ladder after an earthquake, a reading on the 1976 swine flu vaccine and a case about a surveillance survey that could fuel stigma. The background explains that, unlike in clinical care, benefits may go to the community while harms fall on individuals, illustrated by quarantine and mandatory vaccination. It stresses ethical practice as a way to build trust, as shown during the 2014 Ebola outbreak, and closes with references.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-016",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Learning objective 3.2: Assess the factors to be considered in determining when public health surveillance requires explicit informed consent from individuals or communities.",
      "pageStart": 86,
      "pageEnd": 93,
      "target": "../sections/sec-016-learning-objective-32-assess-the-factors-to-be-c.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "determining when public health surveillance requires explicit informed \nconsent from individuals or communities.\nCarl Coleman\nSession timeline (60 min)\n0–15 min\n(15 min)\n16–20 min\n(5 min)\n21–35 min\n(15 min)\n36–56 min\n(20 min)\n56–60 min\n(5 min)\nIntroduction\nReading\nTeam preparation\nTeam presentations \nand discussion\nSummary \nand conclusion\nInstruction strategy\n1.\t\nThe facilitator presents a general overview of the issue, using the slides (15 min).\n2.\t\nThe facilitator distributes the case study and gives participants 5 min to read it (5 min).\n3.\t\nThe facilitator divides the group into teams of t",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "A training module on the factors that determine when public health surveillance requires explicit informed consent from individuals or communities. Its 60-minute session plan uses a case of a blood survey for multidrug-resistant tuberculosis, with facilitator notes on whether it is research or surveillance, risks of identification and stigma, what information to disclose and whether patients may refuse. The background defines informed consent, notes its place in the Nuremberg Code, the Declaration of Helsinki and CIOMS guidelines, and sets out the arguments for it. It then considers when consent may be waived or modified, ending with references.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-017",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Learning objective 3.3: Evaluate the measures required to protect privacy and confidentiality in an emergency.",
      "pageStart": 93,
      "pageEnd": 100,
      "target": "../sections/sec-017-learning-objective-33-evaluate-the-measures-requ.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "privacy and confidentiality in an emergency.\nGhaiath Hussein\nSession timeline (90 min)\n0–5 min\n(5 min)\n6–15 min\n(10 min)\n16-20 min\n(5 min)\n21–45 min\n(25 min)\n46–60 min\n(15 min)\n61–85 min\n(25 min)\n86–90 min\n(5 min)\nIntroduction\nDiscussion\nReading\nTeam \npreparation\nGroup \ndiscussion\nTeam \npresentations \nand discussion\nSummary and \nconclusion\nInstruction strategy\n1.\t\nThe facilitator briefly describes the learning objective (5 min).\n2.\t\nThe facilitator probes the understanding of the trainees of the concepts of privacy and confidentiality \nand asks them to share any professional or personal experi",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "A training module on protecting privacy and confidentiality during emergencies. Its 90-minute session plan centres on a case in which a village leader asks a survey team for collected data, with suggested protective steps such as engaging leaders beforehand, avoiding identifiable data and transporting questionnaires in locked boxes. The background defines privacy and confidentiality and explains why emergencies threaten them, through less controlled settings, wider data sharing, improvised recording and limited resources for secure storage. It justifies the duty of confidentiality through beneficence, non-maleficence, autonomy and trustworthiness, and ends with references.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-018",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Learning objective 3.4: Describe specific measures required to protect and collect data and biological materials during public health surveillance.",
      "pageStart": 100,
      "pageEnd": 106,
      "target": "../sections/sec-018-learning-objective-34-describe-specific-measures.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "protect and collect data and biological materials during public health \nsurveillance.\nCarl Coleman\nSession timeline (60 min)\n0–15 min\n(15 min)\n16–20 min\n(5 min)\n21–35 min\n(15 min)\n36–55 min\n(20 min)\n56–60 min\n(5 min)\nIntroduction\nReading\nTeam preparation\nTeam presentations \nand discussion\nSummary and \nconclusion\nInstruction strategy\n1.\t\nThe facilitator presents a general overview of the issue, using the slides as a guide (15 min).\n2.\t\nThe facilitator distributes the case study and gives participants time to read it (5 min).\n3.\t\nThe facilitator divides the group into teams of three to four, ask",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "A training module on measures needed to protect data and biological materials collected during public health surveillance. Its 60-minute session plan uses a household blood-sampling case, with facilitator notes on what participants should be told, the risk of identifying positive individuals in small communities, safeguards such as broad geographical coding and restricted access, and whether results should be returned. The background describes ethical issues raised by specimens, including perceived intrusiveness, stigma that can extend to whole communities, and exploitation when products derived from samples are unaffordable locally, citing Indonesia's 2007 decision to stop sharing avian flu samples. References on stored biological materials close the section.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-019",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Learning objective 3.5: Describe circumstances in which the common good might overrule individual autonomy during public health surveillance.",
      "pageStart": 106,
      "pageEnd": 111,
      "target": "../sections/sec-019-learning-objective-35-describe-circumstances-in.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "good might overrule individual autonomy during public health \nsurveillance.\nMichael J. Selgelid\nSession timeline (60 min)\n0–15 min\n(15 min)\n16–20 min\n(5 min)\n21–35 min\n(15 min)\n36–55 min\n(20 min)\n56–60 min\n(5 min)\nIntroduction\nReading\nTeam preparation\nTeam presentations \nand discussion\nSummary and \nconclusion\nInstruction strategy\n1.\t\nThe facilitator presents a general overview of the issue, using the attached slides as a guide.\n2.\t\nThe facilitator distributes the case study and the accompanying questions and gives participants 5 min \nto read it.\n3.\t\nThe facilitator then divides the group into",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "A training module on circumstances in which the common good may override individual autonomy in public health surveillance. It sets out a 60-minute team-based case discussion and explains that measures such as surveillance, notification, mandatory testing or treatment and quarantine each infringe rights such as privacy, consent and freedom of movement. The background explains why autonomy matters ethically and discusses when such infringements can be justified, ending with references including Mill's On liberty.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/figure-img-p111-1",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Figure",
        "doco:Figure"
      ],
      "kind": "figure",
      "title": "",
      "pageStart": 111,
      "pageEnd": 111,
      "target": "../images/img-p111-1.webp",
      "narrative": "draft",
      "content": "Photograph of a crowded tented field hospital with rows of beds occupied by patients, attended by health workers and relatives.",
      "truncated": false,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": null
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-020",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Core competence 4: Ability to identify conflict between the common good and individual autonomy in research and clinical trials during emergency response",
      "pageStart": 111,
      "pageEnd": 113,
      "target": "../sections/sec-020-core-competence-4-ability-to-identify-conflict-b.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "Ability to identify conflict \nbetween the common good \nand individual autonomy \nin research and clinical trials \nduring emergency response\nHaiti Earthquake January 12, 2010. \nHospital Universite d’Etat D’Haiti.\nSource:  WHO/AMRO/Victor Ariscain\nCore competence 4: Ability to identify conflict between the common \ngood and individual autonomy in research and clinical trials during \nemergency response\nResearch is poised to become an integral part of the response to emergencies with public health consequences. \nLike other public health activities, however, public health research might lead to harm,",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Introduces the fourth core competence of the course, on conflicts between the common good and individual autonomy in research and clinical trials during emergencies. It outlines four learning objectives on harms and benefits of research, moral theories and frameworks, waivers of consent in critical care, and improving consent in traditional communities and low-resource settings.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-021",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Learning objective 4.1: Identify potential harm and benefit to individuals and communities resulting from conducting research in emergencies.",
      "pageStart": 113,
      "pageEnd": 122,
      "target": "../sections/sec-021-learning-objective-41-identify-potential-harm-an.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "individuals and communities resulting from conducting research in \nemergencies.\nLisa Schwartz\nSession timeline (60 min)\n1–15 min\n(15 min)\n16–25 min\n(10 min)\n26–35 min\n(10 min)\n36–50 min\n(15 min)\n51–60 min\n(10 min)\nIntroduction\nSlide presentation \nand class discussion\nSmall group \ndiscussion\nCase study and \ndiscussion\nSummary and \nconclusion\nInstruction strategy\n1.\t\nThe facilitator divides the group into teams of three or four participants.\n2.\t\nThe facilitator asks half of the small groups to discuss the potential harm to individuals and to \ncommunities that can result from conducting research",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "A training module on the potential harms and benefits to individuals and communities of conducting research during emergencies. Its 60-minute session plan has groups list harms and benefits, optionally view videos on the 1918 influenza pandemic, and discuss conflicting ethical principles and quotations on population health versus individual rights. The background notes that emergency research has sometimes caused disability and death, and raises questions about compromising scientific standards, who bears the risks of unapproved treatments and who gets first access to scarce new treatments. It stresses fair distribution of research benefits and burdens and barriers to valid consent in traditional or low-resource settings, ending with references including reports on drug trials in Nigeria.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-022",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Learning objective 4.2: Discuss moral theories, and identify frameworks applicable to research in emergencies.",
      "pageStart": 122,
      "pageEnd": 128,
      "target": "../sections/sec-022-learning-objective-42-discuss-moral-theories-and.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "applicable to research in emergencies.\nMichael J. Selgelid\nSession timeline (60 min)\n0–15 min\n(15 min)\n16–25 min\n(10 min)\n26–55 min\n(30 min)\n56–60 min\n(5 min)\nSlide presentation of slides \n2–5 and discussion\nSlide presentation of \nslides 6–7\nSlide presentation of slide \n8 and discussion\nSummary and conclusion\nInstruction strategy\nFor facilitators: This session should be run as an interactive, discussion‑oriented seminar with the slides \nprovided.\n1.\t\nThe facilitator describes the major ethical frameworks (slides 2–5) and elicits participants’ opinions on \ntheir applicability to research in eme",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Provides a 60-minute seminar plan for learning objective 4.2 on moral theories, in which the facilitator presents major ethical frameworks and leads discussion of their fit for research in emergencies. The background explains how utilitarianism, egalitarianism, libertarianism and rights-based theories each stress different values, and argues for a pluralistic approach. It then outlines a set of principles to weigh, each to be discussed in terms of justification, legitimacy and practicality, and closes with references including the Siracusa principles.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-023",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Learning objective 4.3: Explain the current norms under which a waiver of consent could be deemed acceptable for research in critical care settings, and assess when they could be applicable to research in emergencies.",
      "pageStart": 128,
      "pageEnd": 133,
      "target": "../sections/sec-023-learning-objective-43-explain-the-current-norms.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "of consent could be deemed acceptable for research in critical care \nsettings, and assess when they could be applicable to research in \nemergencies.\nLisa Schwartz\nSession timeline (75 min)\n0–10 min\n(10 min)\n11–25 min\n(15 min)\n26–40 min\n(15 min)\n41–60 min\n(20 min)\n61–75 min\n(15 min)\nSmall group \ndiscussion\nGroup discussion\nSlide presentation\nCase study and \ndiscussion\nSummary and \nconclusion\nInstruction strategy\n1.\t\nThe facilitator divides the group into teams of three or four participants.\n2.\t\nThe facilitator asks half the small groups to find arguments to justify the assertion “Research shoul",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Sets out a 75-minute session for learning objective 4.3 on when a waiver of informed consent may be acceptable for research in critical care and emergencies, using small-group debate for and against research without consent. The facilitator then outlines current norms for consent waivers and revisits the Trovan and SARS case studies, asking whether minimal-risk conditions were met. Notes for facilitators discuss proxy consent by stressed parents, and the section ends with references on research with critically ill patients.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-024",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Learning objective 4.4: Explain the processes required to improve informed consent to research in emergencies, with particular consideration of traditional communities and low‑resource settings.",
      "pageStart": 133,
      "pageEnd": 141,
      "target": "../sections/sec-024-learning-objective-44-explain-the-processes-requ.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "informed consent to research in emergencies, with particular \nconsideration of traditional communities and low‑resource settings.\nCaroline Clarinval\nSession timeline (90 min)\n0–15 min\n(15 min)\n16–25 min\n(10 min)\n26–45 min\n(20 min)\n46–65 min\n(20 min)\n66–85 min\n(20 min)\n86–90 min\n(5 min)\nIntroduction\nSlide presentation\nReading\nGroup work\nDiscussion\nSummary and conclusion\nInstruction strategy\n1.\t\nThe facilitator introduces the learning objective (15 min).\n2.\t\nThe facilitator presents the slides (10 min). See: http://www.who.int/ethics/topics/outbreaks-emergencies/en/\nFor facilitators: The main is",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Presents a 90-minute session for learning objective 4.4 on improving informed consent in emergency research, especially in traditional communities and low-resource settings. Participants read the Trovan case study and related news items, then split into groups to examine questions such as the ethical challenges of such settings and how the sponsor could have avoided wrongdoing. Facilitator notes cover language and cultural barriers, community permission, and the heightened vulnerability and risk of exploitation of participants during emergencies. The section includes background material and closes with references, including studies on consent comprehension in Ghana and clinical trial ethics in Nigeria.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/figure-img-p141-1",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Figure",
        "doco:Figure"
      ],
      "kind": "figure",
      "title": "",
      "pageStart": 141,
      "pageEnd": 141,
      "target": "../images/img-p141-1.webp",
      "narrative": "draft",
      "content": "Collage of journal covers including the Weekly epidemiological record, Public health ethics, the Bulletin of the World Health Organization, Monash Bioethics Review and Asian Bioethics Review.",
      "truncated": false,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": null
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-025",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Core competence 5: Ability to explain how publication ethics are related to public health surveillance or research in emergencies",
      "pageStart": 141,
      "pageEnd": 143,
      "target": "../sections/sec-025-core-competence-5-ability-to-explain-how-publica.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "Ability to explain how \npublication ethics are related \nto public health surveillance or \nresearch in emergencies\nCore competence 5: Ability to explain how publication ethics are \nrelated to public health surveillance or research in emergencies\nWhen new knowledge is generated to protect the public during an emergency, there is a moral obligation \nto share and publicize the relevant findings in due time. Such scientific knowledge can be obtained during \nroutine surveillance. Therefore, data collection might have been initiated without proper ethics oversight. \nIn such cases, it is important tha",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Introduces core competence 5, on how publication ethics relate to surveillance and research in emergencies, and lists its three learning objectives. These cover publishing data gathered during surveillance or routine care, publication bias, and ethical duties around ownership of scientific data.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-026",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Learning objective 5.1: Explain the conditions in which data gathered during public health surveillance or routine clinical management can be published as scientific knowledge.",
      "pageStart": 143,
      "pageEnd": 149,
      "target": "../sections/sec-026-learning-objective-51-explain-the-conditions-in.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "during public health surveillance or routine clinical management can be \npublished as scientific knowledge.\nPhilippe Calain\nSession timeline (75 min)\n0–15 min\n(15 min)\n16–35 min\n(20 min)\n36–40 min\n(5 min)\n41–60 min\n(20 min)\n61–75 min\n(15 min)\nIntroduction\nReading\nRole play and \npresentation\nGroup discussion\nSummary and \nconclusion\nInstruction strategy\n1.\t\nThe facilitator introduces the module and lists the conditions in which data could be ethically \ndisseminated as scientific knowledge.\n2.\t\nThe facilitator distributes the paper by Balasegaram et al. (2006) and asks participants to read it, \np",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Outlines a 75-minute session for learning objective 5.1 on when data from surveillance or routine clinical care may be published as scientific knowledge, built around a role play in which the facilitator seeks post-hoc ethics clearance for a paper by Balasegaram et al. Groups decide whether to grant clearance, weighing the lack of patient information and prior ethics review against social benefit. Background text stresses the strong obligation to share emergency findings quickly, and the section ends with references.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/figure-vfig-p145",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Figure",
        "doco:Figure"
      ],
      "kind": "figure",
      "title": "",
      "pageStart": 145,
      "pageEnd": 145,
      "target": "../figures/vfig-p145.webp",
      "narrative": "draft",
      "content": "Figure 1, research to improve health systems (Remme et al., 2010): a three-band diagram. Research domains are shown as nested brackets of increasing size: operational, implementation and health system. Their corresponding users are health care providers, programme managers, and health system managers/policy makers, and a widening wedge shows research utility ranging from local to broad.",
      "truncated": false,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": null
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-027",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Learning objective 5.2: Explain what is meant by “publication bias” and how it might affect the response to emergencies.",
      "pageStart": 149,
      "pageEnd": 157,
      "target": "../sections/sec-027-learning-objective-52-explain-what-is-meant-by-p.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "how it might affect the response to emergencies.\nMaxwell J. Smith\nSession timeline (90 min)\n0–20 min\n(20 min)\n21–40 min\n(20 min)\n41–55 min\n(15 min)\n56–85 min\n(30 min)\n86-90\n(5 min)\nIntroduction\nReading\nVideo and group\ndiscussion\nCase study and\ndiscussion\nSummary and\nconclusion\nInstruction strategy\n1.\t\nThe facilitator provides background information on publication bias and its effects on emergency \npreparedness and response.\nFor facilitators: Allow time for questions and discussion.\n2.\t\nThe facilitator distributes copies of the papers by Godlee and Loder (2010) and Cohen (2009) to the \nparticip",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Gives a 90-minute session plan for learning objective 5.2 on publication bias and its effect on emergency response, combining readings by Godlee and Loder and by Cohen, a news video about the antiviral Tamiflu, and a case study. Small groups discuss whether the case shows publication bias, how it could be prevented or mitigated, and how it could affect emergency response. Background material explains that emergency preparedness relies on research evidence and describes proposed methods for addressing publication bias. References at the end include WHO documents on H5N1 influenza and the Model List of Essential Medicines.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-028",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Learning objective 5.3: Explain the ethical obligations of researchers, public health practitioners and publishers regarding ownership of scientific data.",
      "pageStart": 157,
      "pageEnd": 165,
      "target": "../sections/sec-028-learning-objective-53-explain-the-ethical-obliga.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "public health practitioners and publishers regarding ownership of \nscientific data.\nMaxwell J. Smith\nSession timeline (120 min)\n0–20 min\n(20 min)\n21–50 min\n(30 min)\n51–65 min\n(15 min)\n66–110 min\n(45 min)\n111–120 min\n(10 min)\nIntroduction\nReading\nVideo and group \ndiscussion\nCase study and \ndiscussion\nSummary and \nconclusion\nInstruction strategy\n1.\t\nThe facilitator provides background information on data ownership, data‑sharing and the corresponding \nethical responsibilities of researchers, public health practitioners and publishers.\nFor facilitators: Allow time for questions and discussion.\n2.",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Presents a 120-minute session for learning objective 5.3 on the ethical obligations of researchers, public health practitioners and publishers regarding ownership of scientific data. After readings and a video about Tamiflu, two groups debate stricter data control versus open data sharing during an emergency, to inform thinking about data-sharing policy. Participants then examine a case study on access to data on oseltamivir effectiveness, weighing data ownership against public benefit. The section closes with references and further reading on drug safety and effectiveness.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-029",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Patient care",
      "pageStart": 165,
      "pageEnd": 167,
      "target": "../sections/sec-029-patient-care.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "",
      "truncated": false,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "empty"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/figure-img-p167-1",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Figure",
        "doco:Figure"
      ],
      "kind": "figure",
      "title": "",
      "pageStart": 167,
      "pageEnd": 167,
      "target": "../images/img-p167-1.webp",
      "narrative": "draft",
      "content": "Night-time photograph of a health worker with a head torch attending to a patient lying on the ground among many others in an outdoor makeshift treatment area, with an intravenous drip stand.",
      "truncated": false,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": null
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-030",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Core competence 6: Ability to define ethically relevant criteria for triage, resource allocation and standard of care in emergency response",
      "pageStart": 167,
      "pageEnd": 169,
      "target": "../sections/sec-030-core-competence-6-ability-to-define-ethically-re.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "Ability to define ethically relevant \ncriteria for triage, resource \nallocation and standard of care \nin emergency response\nHaiti Earthquake January 12, 2010 - Jimani DOR. \nHospital El Buen Samaritano\nSource:  WHO/AMRO/Victor Ariscain\nCore competence 6: Ability to define ethically relevant criteria for \ntriage, resource allocation and standard of care in emergency response\nTriage and rationing are often at the centre of responses to emergencies crises. Specific criteria and general \nframeworks have been drawn up for these activities; they are discussed in learning objective 6.1. This \ndiscussi",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Introduces core competence 6, on ethical criteria for triage, resource allocation and standards of care in emergency response, illustrated by a photo from the 2010 Haiti earthquake. It lists four learning objectives covering triage and rationing frameworks, altered standards of care, benefit-sharing with communities under surveillance, and equitable access to unproven treatments.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-031",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Learning objective 6.1: Discuss ethical frameworks and criteria for triage and rationing in emergencies.",
      "pageStart": 169,
      "pageEnd": 178,
      "target": "../sections/sec-031-learning-objective-61-discuss-ethical-frameworks.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "triage and rationing in emergencies.\nA.M. Viens\nSession timeline (90 min)\n0–15 min\n(15 min)\n16–20 min\n(5 min)\n21–35 min\n(15 min)\n36–45 min\n(10 min)\n46–70 min\n(25 min)\n71–80 min\n(10 min)\n81–90 min\n(10 min)\nIntroduction\nSmall groups \ndiscussion\nLarge group \ndiscussion\nLarge group \ndiscussion\nReading\nDiscussion\nSummary and \nconclusion\nInstruction strategy\n1.\t\nThe facilitator introduces the module and provides background information on triage and rationing, \nincluding the criteria that could be used in emergencies.\n2.\t\nThe facilitator separates the group and provides each small group with one (or",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Sets out a 90-minute session for learning objective 6.1 on ethical frameworks and criteria for triage and rationing in emergencies. Small groups consider questions such as which resources may need allocating, who should make triage decisions, which criteria should never be used, and whether to maximize lives or life-years saved. Further large-group discussion and a reading follow, with background on triage criteria and conflicts between the common good and individual patients. The section ends with references, including WHO discussion papers on ethics in pandemic influenza planning.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-032",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Learning objective 6.2: Understand how criteria for standards of care and treatment can be altered during emergencies.",
      "pageStart": 178,
      "pageEnd": 184,
      "target": "../sections/sec-032-learning-objective-62-understand-how-criteria-fo.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "and treatment can be altered during emergencies.\nPhilippe Calain and Renaud F. Boulanger\nSession timeline (90 min)\n0–10 min\n(10 min)\n11–15 min\n(5 min)\n16-30 min\n(15 min)\n31-35 min\n(5 min)\n36-75 min\n(40 min)\n76-90 min\n(15 min)\nIntroduction\nReading\nVideo and group \ndiscussion (case study 1)\nReading\nWrite-up and group \ndiscussion (case study 2)\nSummary and \nconclusion\nInstruction strategy\nFor facilitators: Make sure that you are familiar with the case studies (see section C and Box 7) before \nbeginning the session.\n1.\t\nThe facilitator introduces the module by drawing a distinction between triage",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Provides a 90-minute session for learning objective 6.2 on how standards of care and treatment may be altered during emergencies, distinguishing this from triage. The first case study uses an article and video about Dr Anna Pou's actions in a hospital after a hurricane to explore moral versus legal responsibility. A second exercise uses scenarios from Levin et al. for individual reflection and group discussion, and the section closes with references.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-033",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Learning objective 6.3: Identify issues of benefit‑sharing with communities under public health surveillance.",
      "pageStart": 184,
      "pageEnd": 191,
      "target": "../sections/sec-033-learning-objective-63-identify-issues-of-benefit.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "communities under public health surveillance.\nDónal O’Mathúna\nSession timeline (105 min)\n0–20 min\n(20 min)\n21–35 min\n(15 min)\n36–40 min\n(5 min)\n41–55 min\n(15 min)\n56–65 min\n(10 min)\n66–70 min\n(5 min)\n71–100 min\n(30 min)\n101–105 min\n(5 min)\nIntroduction\nIndividual \nreflection\nReading\nGroup \ndiscussion\nClass \ndiscussion\nCase \npresentation\nCase \ndiscussion\nSummary and \nconclusion\nInstruction strategy\n1.\t\nThe facilitator introduces the module and provides a brief background to the concept of benefit‑sharing \nand its historical evolution.\n2.\t\nThe facilitator asks the participants the following ques",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Outlines a 105-minute session for learning objective 6.3 on benefit-sharing with communities under public health surveillance, starting with the UNESCO Declaration on Bioethics and Human Rights and the line between benefits and undue inducement. Participants read Simm (2007) and discuss in groups how benefit-sharing applies to surveillance, followed by a case presentation and discussion. Background covers the history of the benefit-sharing concept. References include the Nagoya Protocol, WHO's Pandemic Influenza Preparedness Framework and the Declaration of Helsinki.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-034",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Learning objective 6.4: Identify issues of equity of access to unproven treatments during research in the course of emergency response.",
      "pageStart": 191,
      "pageEnd": 201,
      "target": "../sections/sec-034-learning-objective-64-identify-issues-of-equity.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "treatments during research in the course of emergency response.\nPhilippe Calain and Renaud F. Boulanger\nSession timeline (60 min)\n0–15 min\n(15 min)\n16–30 min\n(15 min)\n31–45 min\n(15 min)\n46–60 min\n(15 min)\nIntroduction\nReading\nDebate\nSummary and conclusion\nInstruction strategy\n1.\t\nThe facilitator introduces the module material.\n2.\t\nThe facilitator distributes copies of the case study for participants to read.\nFor facilitators: The case concerns the availability of post‑exposure prophylaxis during an outbreak of \nEbola haemorrhagic fever in central Africa. It illustrates the conflict between gen",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Sets out a 60-minute session with reading and a debate for learning objective 6.4 on equitable access to unproven treatments during emergency research. The case study concerns post-exposure prophylaxis during an Ebola outbreak in central Africa and the tension between generating robust trial data and compassionate use to save lives now. Facilitator notes refer to the 2014 west African Ebola epidemic and a WHO panel convened that August on the ethics of investigational interventions. The section ends with references on trial designs and the ethics of experimental Ebola treatments.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/figure-img-p201-1",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Figure",
        "doco:Figure"
      ],
      "kind": "figure",
      "title": "",
      "pageStart": 201,
      "pageEnd": 201,
      "target": "../images/img-p201-1.webp",
      "narrative": "draft",
      "content": "Photograph of a health worker in a patterned headscarf giving oral drops to an infant held by a woman wearing a blue burqa.",
      "truncated": false,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": null
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-035",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Core competence 7: Ability to discuss the professional duties of health care workers during public health surveillance or research in emergencies",
      "pageStart": 201,
      "pageEnd": 203,
      "target": "../sections/sec-035-core-competence-7-ability-to-discuss-the-profess.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "Ability to discuss the professional \nduties of health care workers \nduring public health surveillance \nor research in emergencies\nA health clinic in Kandahar, \nAfghanistan, 2008.\nSource: UN Photo/Sebastian Rich\nCore competence 7: Ability to discuss the professional duties of \nhealth care workers during public health surveillance or research in \nemergencies\nEmergencies are conducive to several types of moral conflict for health care workers. One classical example \nis the duty to care for victims of contagious diseases. When health care providers act as researchers during an \nemergency, addition",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Introduces core competence 7, on the professional duties of health care workers during surveillance or research in emergencies, with a photo of a clinic in Kandahar. It notes conflicts such as the duty to care, therapeutic misconception and conflicts of interest, and lists three learning objectives.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-036",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Learning objective 7.1: Distinguish three ethics frameworks: medical care ethics, public health ethics and research ethics, and explore the ways in which the values and principles that guide these frameworks diverge or overlap.",
      "pageStart": 203,
      "pageEnd": 209,
      "target": "../sections/sec-036-learning-objective-71-distinguish-three-ethics-f.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "care ethics, public health ethics and research ethics, and explore the \nways in which the values and principles that guide these frameworks \ndiverge or overlap.\nLeigh‑Anne Gillespie and Lisa Schwartz\nSession timeline (100 min)\n0–5 min\n(5 min)\n6–25 min\n(20 min)\n26–45 min\n(20 min)\n46–75 min\n(30 min)\n76–95 min\n(20 min)\n96–105 min\n(10 min)\nIntroduction\nTemplate and \ndiscussion\nVideo and group \ndiscussion\nCase study and \ndiscussion\nRole‑play\nSummary and \nconclusion\nInstruction strategy\n1.\t\nThe facilitator introduces the different aims of medical care, public health and research and discusses \ntheir",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Presents a training session plan for learning objective 7.1, which asks trainees to compare the aims, values and principles of medical care ethics, public health ethics and research ethics. The 100-minute session moves from an introduction through small-group work with a comparison template, a video on disaster ethics, a case study, a role-play and a closing summary. Facilitator notes supply discussion questions on whether clinical values can be carried into public health interventions and research in emergencies. The section ends with a list of readings and references on clinical, public health and disaster ethics.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-037",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Learning objective 7.2: Explain what is meant by “therapeutic misconception” and how it could affect the duties of health care workers in emergencies.",
      "pageStart": 209,
      "pageEnd": 218,
      "target": "../sections/sec-037-learning-objective-72-explain-what-is-meant-by-t.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "misconception” and how it could affect the duties of health care \nworkers in emergencies.\nElysee Nouvet, Lisa Schwartz and Michael Baxter\nSession timeline (75 min)\n0–10 min\n(10 min)\n11–25 min\n(15 min)\n26–45 min\n(20 min)\n46–65 min\n(20 min)\n66–75 min\n(10 min)\nIntroduction\nDiscussion\nCase study and \ndiscussion\nRole‑play\nSummary and \nconclusion\nInstruction strategy\n1.\t\nThe facilitator introduces “therapeutic misconception” and reviews why it may be an ethical problem.\n2.\t\nHaving introduced the issue of risks and the three strategies to reduce them, the facilitator asks \nparticipants to reflect on",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Sets out a 75-minute training session on the concept of therapeutic misconception and how it bears on the duties of health care workers who take part in research during emergencies. Facilitators introduce the idea, review three strategies for helping people tell clinical research apart from medical care, and ask participants whether these are workable given language barriers, trauma and scarce resources. A case study and role-play follow, with questions on how the misconception arises and how a physician might reduce it. The section closes with references, including qualitative studies of research participation and work on empirical bioethics.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-038",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Learning objective 7.3: Explain the potential conflicts of interest of health care workers participating in emergency research activities.",
      "pageStart": 218,
      "pageEnd": 229,
      "target": "../sections/sec-038-learning-objective-73-explain-the-potential-conf.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "health care workers participating in emergency research activities.\nMarie‑Josée Potvin and Bryn Williams‑Jones\nSession timeline (90 min)\n0–15 min\n(15 min)\n16–25 min\n(10 min)\n26–55 min\n(30 min)\n56–85 min\n(30 min)\n86–90 min\n(5 min)\nIntroduction\nPresentation of \nproblem‑solving tools\nCase study and discussion,\nphase 1\nCase study and discussion, \nphases 2 and 3\nSummary and \nconclusion\nInstruction strategy\nFor facilitators: This session is highly interactive; it requires that you spend time familiarizing yourself with \nthe content and format of the session.\n1.\t\nThe facilitator starts the session by",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Provides a 90-minute, highly interactive session plan on conflicts of interest faced by health care workers who join research activities during emergencies. The facilitator presents definitions, then problem-solving tools for identifying, evaluating and managing such conflicts, and a model for handling them ethically. A multi-part case study is revealed in stages, with a discussion guide steering the group through three phases of analysis. The section ends with references on research integrity and responsible conduct of research.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/figure-img-p229-1",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Figure",
        "doco:Figure"
      ],
      "kind": "figure",
      "title": "",
      "pageStart": 229,
      "pageEnd": 229,
      "target": "../images/img-p229-1.webp",
      "narrative": "draft",
      "content": "Photograph of four people searching through shelves piled high with bundles of paper records.",
      "truncated": false,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": null
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-039",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Glossary",
      "pageStart": 229,
      "pageEnd": 235,
      "target": "../sections/sec-039-glossary.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "Staff at the Medical Records Office sort through patient’s \nat Karapitayam Hospital, Galle. The hospital was not \naffected by the Tsunami as it is away from the seafront \nand on higher ground. WHO is providing computers \nand training in Epi Info software so that they can enter \npatient data and track certain health parameters. \nSource: WHO/Gary Hampton\nThis glossary provides definitions of common concepts, principles and values in health ethics. For many of \nthe terms, a number of definitions are available. This glossary is therefore not intended to be definitive but \nto aid understanding of c",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "A glossary that defines common concepts, principles and values used in health ethics, noting that the definitions are aids to understanding rather than definitive. Entries include terms such as accountability for reasonableness, autonomy and beneficence, each with supporting citations. It opens with a photo caption about WHO support to a hospital medical records office in Sri Lanka and ends with a numbered reference list.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/figure-img-p235-1",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Figure",
        "doco:Figure"
      ],
      "kind": "figure",
      "title": "",
      "pageStart": 235,
      "pageEnd": 235,
      "target": "../images/img-p235-1.webp",
      "narrative": "draft",
      "content": "Photograph of a large camp of white-sheeted shelters spread across a plain, with mountains in the background.",
      "truncated": false,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": null
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-040",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Annex I. List of modules and course timetables",
      "pageStart": 235,
      "pageEnd": 238,
      "target": "../sections/sec-040-annex-i-list-of-modules-and-course-timetables.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "List of modules \nand course timetables\nRefugee camp, Goma\nSource: WHO/Christopher Black\nList of modules\nOverview: Ethics of epidemics, emergencies and disasters\b\n90 min\nCore Competence 1: Ability to analyse the boundaries between public health practice (including \nsurveillance) and research, and their ethical implications in emergencies\nLearning Objective 1.1. Distinguish between public health surveillance and public health research\n60 min\nLearning Objective 1.2. Identify the scope of activities that could qualify as “research” during \nemergency response and would normally require research eth",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Lists every module of the emergency ethics course, from the overview through the core competences and their learning objectives, with the time allotted to each. It introduces the sample course timetables that follow.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-041",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Practice‑oriented two‑day session",
      "pageStart": 238,
      "pageEnd": 240,
      "target": "../sections/sec-041-practiceoriented-twoday-session.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "Day 1\n9:00 – 9:15 Opening remarks\n9:15 – 10:15 First session\nLearning Objective 1.1. Distinguish between public health surveillance and public health research\n60 min\n10:15 – 10:30 Break\n10:30 – 12:15 Second session\nLearning Objective 7.1. Distinguish three ethics frameworks: medical care ethics, public health \nethics and research ethics, and explore the ways in which the values and principles that guide these \nframeworks diverge or overlap\n105 min\n12:15 – 13:00 Lunch\n13:00 – 14:30 Third session\nLearning Objective 6.1. Discuss ethical frameworks and criteria for triage and rationing in \nemergen",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Gives a sample two-day timetable for a practice-oriented version of the course, assigning learning objectives to timed sessions with breaks. Day 1 covers topics such as surveillance versus research, the three ethics frameworks, and triage and altered standards of care, while day 2 turns to ethics review, consent and use of surveillance data.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-042",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Research‑oriented two‑day session",
      "pageStart": 240,
      "pageEnd": 243,
      "target": "../sections/sec-042-researchoriented-twoday-session.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "Day 1\n9:00 – 9:15 Opening remarks\n9:15 – 10:15 First session\nLearning Objective 1.1. Distinguish between public health surveillance and public health research\n60 min\n10:15 – 10:30 Break\n10:30 – 12:15 Second session\nLearning Objective 7.1. Distinguish three ethics frameworks: medical care ethics, public health \nethics and research ethics, and explore the ways in which the values and principles that guide these \nframeworks diverge or overlap\n105 min\n12:15 – 13:00 Lunch\n13:00 – 14:30 Third session\nLearning Objective 1.2. Identify the scope of activities that could qualify as “research” during \nem",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Gives a sample two-day timetable for a research-oriented version of the course, setting out which learning objectives are covered in each timed session. Sessions address topics such as what counts as research in emergencies, harms and benefits of research, conflicts of interest, therapeutic misconception and ownership of scientific data.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/figure-img-p243-1",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Figure",
        "doco:Figure"
      ],
      "kind": "figure",
      "title": "",
      "pageStart": 243,
      "pageEnd": 243,
      "target": "../images/img-p243-1.webp",
      "narrative": "draft",
      "content": "Photograph of a busy hospital ward with beds under mosquito nets, patients and carers, oxygen concentrators, and a man in blue scrubs walking down the aisle.",
      "truncated": false,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": null
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/prose-sec-043",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Prose",
        "doco:Section"
      ],
      "kind": "prose",
      "title": "Annex II. Case studies",
      "pageStart": 243,
      "pageEnd": 276,
      "target": "../sections/sec-043-annex-ii-case-studies.md",
      "narrative": null,
      "content": "Case studies\nA doctor inspects patients  in an MSF supported hospital in \nAweil,Northern Bar El Ghazal in Southern Sudan on January 14, 2011\nSource: IRIN/Siegfried Modola \nCore Competence 1\nCase Study 1: Outbreak of Haemorrhagic Fever (p. 12)\nUsed in: Overview: Ethics in emergencies\nSource: Renaud Boulanger and Selena Knight\nGroup 1: Allocation of intravenous fluids during an outbreak of viral haemorrhagic fever\nA deadly form of viral haemorrhagic fever has struck your community. The signs and symptoms of the disease \ninclude high fever and increased susceptibility to bleeding. Manifestations",
      "truncated": true,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": {
        "status": "draft",
        "text": "Annex II collects the case studies used throughout the course on ethics in epidemics, emergencies and disasters, grouped by core competence and cross-referenced to the sessions that use them. The first case asks groups how to allocate scarce intravenous fluid sets during an outbreak of viral haemorrhagic fever with limited diagnostic capacity. Later cases cover topics drawn from the course objectives, each followed by discussion questions on how problems might have been handled differently. The annex ends with contact details for WHO's Global Health Ethics Unit.",
        "state": "draft",
        "draftedBy": {
          "kind": "agent",
          "id": "claude-code",
          "model": "not-disclosed"
        },
        "draftedAt": "2026-11-11"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "library/10665-196326/blocks/figure-img-p276-1",
      "types": [
        "folio-assistant-core:Figure",
        "doco:Figure"
      ],
      "kind": "figure",
      "title": "",
      "pageStart": 276,
      "pageEnd": 276,
      "target": "../images/img-p276-1.webp",
      "narrative": "draft",
      "content": "ISBN barcode with the number 9789241549349.",
      "truncated": false,
      "provenance": "ingested",
      "summary": null
    }
  ]
}
