Lean vacuity audit
Inspect Lean declarations chapter by chapter for proofs that type-check, are sorry-free and axiom-clean, and still carry no mathematical content — assuming what they claim, concluding something trivially true, or resting on a false premise.
Skills it satisfies
A skill states the capability; this Tool is one way to exercise it. Each skill’s declared input and output contract follows, where it has one.
lean-proof-vacuity-audit
Detect and fix Lean “vacuous proof” anti-patterns — declarations that type-check, are sorry-free and axiom-clean, and whose statement matches the .md, yet carry NO mathematical content (they assume what they claim, conclude something trivially true, or rest on a false premise). These slip past proof-statement-integrity (which only checks signature-stability + an axiom sweep), so detection is semantic and agent-checked. Use when auditing Lean for circular / vacuous / trivially-true proofs, after a batch proof-statement-integrity normalization (the batch “wrap the conclusion in a structure field and project it” fix produces these), or when a “theorem” looks too easy. Emits per-block QA sidecar params under the proof-no-* criteria.
Source: folio-assistant-sci/skills/content/folio-paper-adapter/lean-proof-vacuity-audit.md.
The skill declares no I/O contract (schemas/skills/lean-proof-vacuity-audit/{input,output}.schema.json).
Inputs and outputs
Each port names a shared type by IRI, so two Tools for one skill can be checked for interchangeability.
| port | type | required | description | constraint | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| in | chapter | Slug | One chapter instead of the whole corpus. | string · pattern ^[a-z0-9][a-z0-9-]*$ · A folio slug, e.g. quantum-observable-universe | |
| in | strict | Flag | boolean · A boolean switch — projects to a bare flag, with no value word | ||
| in | checkAxioms | Flag | Axiom-cleanliness is a separate question from vacuity: a proof can be axiom-clean and still assume its conclusion. | boolean · A boolean switch — projects to a bare flag, with no value word | |
| in | json | Flag | boolean · A boolean switch — projects to a bare flag, with no value word | ||
| out | findings | Text | Sorry inventory and trivial-truth detections. Sibling of lean-coverage, not an alternative to it: that one COUNTS what is proved, this one asks whether a proof says anything. | string · A short single-line human string. Not admissible as a command-line argument. |
Processes and tasks
No process step names a skill this Tool satisfies.
How it is deployed and reached
- Command line. From the repository root:
bun run folio-assistant-sci/scripts/lean-audit.ts. - GitHub Actions. No workflow in this checkout runs its command.
As an API: its operation in the OpenAPI document and the MCP tool list of its layer.
| install | none |
| runtime | bun |
| network | no |
What it is made of
| role | file | |
|---|---|---|
| definition | folio-assistant-sci/tools/lean-audit/lean-audit.ts | |
| script | folio-assistant-sci/scripts/lean-audit.ts |
Linked data
The Tool is published as its own JSON-LD document at its IRI, https://litlfred.github.io/folio-assistant/folio-assistant-sci/tools/lean-audit.jsonld, partOf its layer’s document. The node below is the definition this page was drawn from, and is embedded in the page as application/ld+json.
{
"@context": "https://litlfred.github.io/folio-assistant/folio-assistant-sci/folio-assistant-sci.context.jsonld",
"@id": "https://litlfred.github.io/folio-assistant/folio-assistant-sci/tools/lean-audit.jsonld",
"@type": "https://litlfred.github.io/cat-harness/v0/ns/Tool",
"partOf": "https://litlfred.github.io/folio-assistant/folio-assistant-sci/folio-assistant-sci.jsonld",
"name": "lean-audit",
"title": "Lean vacuity audit",
"description": "Inspect Lean declarations chapter by chapter for proofs that type-check, are sorry-free and axiom-clean, and still carry no mathematical content — assuming what they claim, concluding something trivially true, or resting on a false premise.",
"install": {
"none": true
},
"invoke": {
"shell": "bun run folio-assistant-sci/scripts/lean-audit.ts"
},
"io": {
"inputs": [
{
"name": "chapter",
"schema": "https://litlfred.github.io/folio-assistant/cat-harness/tool-types.schema.json#/$defs/Slug",
"description": "One chapter instead of the whole corpus.",
"required": false,
"arg": {
"flag": "--chapter"
}
},
{
"name": "strict",
"schema": "https://litlfred.github.io/folio-assistant/cat-harness/tool-types.schema.json#/$defs/Flag",
"required": false,
"arg": {
"flag": "--strict"
}
},
{
"name": "checkAxioms",
"schema": "https://litlfred.github.io/folio-assistant/cat-harness/tool-types.schema.json#/$defs/Flag",
"description": "Axiom-cleanliness is a separate question from vacuity: a proof can be axiom-clean and still assume its conclusion.",
"required": false,
"arg": {
"flag": "--check-axioms"
}
},
{
"name": "json",
"schema": "https://litlfred.github.io/folio-assistant/cat-harness/tool-types.schema.json#/$defs/Flag",
"required": false,
"arg": {
"flag": "--json"
}
}
],
"outputs": [
{
"name": "findings",
"schema": "https://litlfred.github.io/folio-assistant/cat-harness/tool-types.schema.json#/$defs/Text",
"description": "Sorry inventory and trivial-truth detections. Sibling of `lean-coverage`, not an alternative to it: that one COUNTS what is proved, this one asks whether a proof says anything."
}
]
},
"satisfies": [
"lean-proof-vacuity-audit"
],
"requirements": {
"runtime": [
"bun"
],
"network": false
}
}